| Authors |
Heath, Oliver ; Del Caño-Ochoa, Francisco ; Baris, Safa ; Carrozzo, Rosalba ; Coman, David ; Distelmaier, Felix ; Ellaway, Carolyn ; Feichtinger, Rene G ; Finocchi, Andrea ; Guerrero-Castillo, Sergio ; Halligan, Rebecca ; Hannibal, Iris ; Kritzer, Amy ; Lichter-Konecki, Uta ; Merkevičius, Kajus ; Panis, Bianca ; Pitceathly, Robert D.S ; Pizzamiglio, Chiara ; Iwanicka-Pronicka, Katarzyna ; Rahman, Shamima ; Seltzer, Laurie ; Siepermann, Meinolf ; Tal, Galit ; Wevers, Ron A ; Ziętkiewicz, Szymon ; Ramón-Maiques, Santiago ; Mayr, Johannes A ; Wortmann, Saskia B |
| Abstract [eng] |
Background: CLPB-related mitochondrial disease causes congenital neutropenia, developmental delay/intellectual disability, progressive brain atrophy, movement disorders, cataracts, and 3-methylglutaconic aciduria. Both monoallelic and biallelic forms exist. This retrospective cohort study compared clinical outcomes and genotype–structure–phenotype correlations across zygosity groups. Methods: Sixty-three individuals (41 biallelic, 22 monoallelic; 6 unpublished) with disease-causing CLPB variants were identified via literature review and a multicenter survey. In silico modeling assessed structural impact. A modified CLPB Disease Burden Index (DBI) quantified severity. Results: Median age at last follow-up was 4.0 years (IQR: 0.25–12.6) in biallelic and 12.0 years (IQR: 5.3–21.0) in monoallelic cases. Death occurred in 66% of biallelic and 23% of monoallelic individuals, with earlier median age at death in biallelic cases (6 months vs 2.4 years). Biallelic cases had significantly higher DBI scores and poorer survival (4-year survival: 50% vs 82%). Stop/stop genotypes were associated with greater disease burden than missense combinations. Structural predictions—particularly variants causing nonsense-mediated decay or ankyrin domain disruption—were stronger survival predictors than zygosity or age of onset. Early-onset disease (<12 months) correlated with more severe progression. Later onset often resulted in milder phenotypes. Hematologic and neurologic features overlapped across zygosity; cataracts and dystonia were more common in biallelic cases. Milestone attainment was poor, with <50% walking or speaking, and only 10–20% doing so on time. Four monoallelic patients received hematopoietic stem cell transplants with mixed outcomes. Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor was associated with improved survival. Conclusions: This is the largest cohort study to date comparing biallelic and monoallelic CLPB deficiency. Structural variant impact—particularly ankyrin domain disruption—emerged as a key prognostic factor. |
